Follow us on:

The Ultimate Source for Wine
Collecting, Cellaring and Serving

Can A Good Wine Come From A Bad Vintage?

In the wonderful and sometimes weird world of wine collecting, few terms are bandied around quite so much as ‘vintage‘.

Of course, anyone with a rudimental understanding of how wine works will know that a vino’s vintage refers to the year that its grapes were grown and harvested, and it’s common to hear of a connoisseur talking of a ‘bad’ or ‘good’ year.

A wine’s vintage can markedly affect how it is received when the bottles are finally released for sale.

If it has come from a good year – which typically refers to light rains during spring, a sunny, dry summer (that wasn’t too hot) and a rainless autumn for a perfect harvest – then the wine is set for a marvellous future.

Should it come from a prestigious vineyard that carries a revered name, it can expect to command a high price, with no shortage of buyers. For a wine that had a less-than-fantastic upbringing, though, the future is a little bleaker. Why?

Bad, as in good?

Many wine collectors – even experienced and knowledgeable ones – are of the opinion that no matter the reputation of a winemaker, they cannot overcome a particularly bad year.

Often, they’d rather take a chance on a case from a little-known vintner of a well-regarded year than purchase a bad-year bottle from an established vineyard – perhaps understandable in the circumstances.

The truth is that collectors could be missing out on some superb wines by following this rationale, as outstanding vinos regularly spring from perceived poor years – and often at rock-bottom prices, too.

There are a multitude of factors that can affect vintage.
Growing conditions, weather patterns and plain old luck all play a part, and what might have been a terrible year in Bordeaux may well be an excellent one in the Hunter Valley – these legendary regions are on opposite sides of the planet, after all!

Even so, a vintner with a modicum of winemaking expertise will always work with what he or she has, and use what the elements bring to create an agreeable wine regardless.


Defying Mother Nature for great wine, every time

Frosted vines in Chablis – a disaster
picture by A.Ibanez


The weather certainly plays a big part in any given vino’s overall quality, but there are still several other factors of wine production that can markedly make a difference.

The precise day on which the grapes are picked, the kind of yeast used, as well as the species of oak chosen for the cask (English, sessile or cork?) will all influence how the final product will taste.

A good winemaker will use everything in their arsenal to ensure that their product is as high a quality as possible.
Into Wine compares an experienced vintner to a professional airline pilot. The latter needs to be prepared for unpredictable conditions during the flight, such as heavy turbulence and storms, and will change their approach accordingly to ensure that they land the plane (and deliver their passengers) safely.

So, great wine from ‘bad’ vintages certainly exists, and because ‘poor years‘ never generate the same level of interest as a good year, prices are often very, very low.

This means that you can stock up your Vintec home wine cellar with a number of beautiful wines at a fraction of the cost.

Posted by The Vintec Club

More in 'COLLECTING' >

Join The Discussion


The Vintec Club is the private club for owners of Vintec and Transtherm wine cellars, and the ultimate online ressource for wine enthusiasts who wish to learn more about the arts of wine collecting, cellaring and serving.
Other articles by The Vintec Club

sign up to our
monthly newsletter

& receive a wine tasting sheet!

join the conversation

latest expert posts

19 Apr 2016 by Jean-Marie Simart

SPOTLIGHT ON: Bistrot Gavroche, Sydney

By JEAN-MARIE SIMART - New French bistrot in Sydney. Did someone say Vin Jaune?... read more

08 Jan 2016 by Mark Baulderstone

The 5 Best Things You Can Do To Wine

Mark Baulderstone, M.D. of Riedel Australia, shares with us his top 5 rituals when it comes to wine enjoyment.... read more


There are no products.